Evaluating Metrics for Fund Selection – II

What works, what doesn’t?

Nicolas Rabener
10 min read
16 Mar 2026

SUMMARY

  • Most common fund selection metrics are ineffective
  • Beating the benchmark is easier in some asset classes than others
  • Fees matter

INTRODUCTION

In June 2025, we published our first article evaluating popular fund selection metrics used by data services such as Morningstar, Lipper, and S&P Global for ranking funds (read Evaluating Metrics for Fund Selection). Our analysis concluded that most of these metrics lack predictive power – for example, identifying the top-performing funds in the past does not guarantee they will continue to outperform in the future.

Keep reading with Institutional

Includes the full research library of 400+ articles, plus Returns Analyzer and Risk Analytics for return and risk contribution analysis.